The advantages and disadvantages of civil disobedience and uncivil disobedience

Lastly, civil disobedience is probably the best way to get the point across when wanting change. A civilization gone with the wind.

Pressure groups that have a large amount of money are able to pay for good lobbyists, therefore resulting in a higher chance of the government listening and making a change for their cause. Civil disobedience has been used by the likes of Mahatma Gandhi and Nelson Mandela.

What are the advantages and disadvantages of civil disobedience?

What moral rules are we bound to follow and how are those rules justified. Thousands marched to the sea and withdrew bowls of water which were left to evaporate in the sun.

The morally binding rules are those needed or social living obviously: By spinning their own cloth, the British were denied this important source of income, and Indians were employed during the off-season when farming was impossible.

Does morality have an objective basis. Civil disobedience cannot be an armed struggle. The disadvantage was that alot of people died. A powerful person or corporation can not run over a small individual or pollute your property without having to pay, …etc.

No one is left behind The Civil War's advantage was that the issue of slavery was finallydealt with, and slavery was abolished. Unfortunately, with pressure groups, there comes lobbying and that can be unfair at times.

Then it was sent back to India and resold at inflated prices.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Pressure Groups, Petitions, and Civil Disobedience

The fundamental rights or civil rights of most democratic countries in the world allow the citizens to engage in peaceful protests. While certain legal restrictions may be imposed in certain places bearing in mind their significance, sensitivity or national interest, there is no law that punishes people just because they are protesting in a nonviolent manner.

Just going out and burning down a building to say it could be done is a lot different than a protest march that disrupts a community. May create more crime. Sometimes it can take a lot of time to win over the hearts and minds of a population group.

This ends up creating bigger problems and the original issues are no longer solved and become lost in the chaos since the government is focusing on the larger problems at hand. The advantages of civil disobedience are that in most cases, it is the most effective way to make change because those stories make the news and gain publicity and awareness for what they are fighting for.

A disadvantage of acivil marriage is that it is not recognized …in all of the 50 UnitedStates and other parts of the world.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Pressure Groups, Petitions and Civil Disobedience

Reciprocity again when one is being denied benefits under the contract one is correspondingly released from certain obligations under the contract.

Based on a Historical Fiction Objection: A widely intuitively recognized duty --in some instances -- to break unjust societial rules Nuremburg precedents Civil rights movement Argument: They are a great way to rise public awareness of matters affecting peoples interests and causes.

On the SCT theory disobedience is never justified the social contract will be undermined if people are allowed to "pick and choose" what laws to obey so, everyone has an obligation to obey all societies rules under all circumstances Reply: Civil disobedience will get you the attention of the press, public figures, the government and international forums but in a positive light.

5 Pros and Cons of Civil Disobedience

Yes Sorry, something has gone wrong. Civil disobedience has the power to cause real change in society, law, government and even in foreign relations.

The government is ruled by people. An advantage of a civil marriage is that the partners do not haveto go through the expense of having a wedding. The disadvantages are that a jury is made of people may not understand the problem.

Whereas if a pressure group does not have the money to pay for a good lobbyist, then there is a far lesser chance that their cause will be heard by the government.

The main benefit of civil disobedience is that the people who practice it are demonstrating against what they perceive as an unfair law. Under what circumstances are we allowed to break the rules?. Feb 28,  · Best Answer: The main benefit of civil disobedience is that the people who practice it are demonstrating against what they perceive as an unfair law.

That they are willing to go to jail for their beliefs helps bring others to sympathize with their cause, and it may bring about desired holidaysanantonio.com: Resolved.

Civil disobedience is a form of civil resistance. It is also a form of protest. However the acts of civil disobedience must be distinguished from typical cases of crime and acts of civil rebellion. The advantages of civil disobedience are that in most cases, it is the most effective way to make change because those stories make the news and gain publicity and.

Oct 04,  · Best Answer: Civil disobedience can force governments to deal with issues that are important to the people. It can also distract governments from real holidaysanantonio.com: Resolved. Civil disobedience rests, as Henry David Thoreau thought, on what are the obligations, of a member of the public, when an unjust situation or law is happening or in force?

The disobedience by Antigone of the non-burial edict and by Haemon of two royal commands are examples of civil disobedience in "Antigone" by Sophocles ( B.C.E. - B.C.E.).

Pros and Cons of Civil Disobedience The advantages and disadvantages of civil disobedience and uncivil disobedience
Rated 0/5 based on 82 review
Benefits/Drawbacks towards Civil Disobedience? | Yahoo Answers